top of page
Case Name
For Publiciation
Hearing Date:
11/12/2024
Hearing Date:
Areas of Law Tags
Case No.:
8983783
For Publiciation
Trial Court:
Trial Court Judge:
Judge Anthony j. Johnson
Main Issue(s) & Sub Issue(s):
1. Did plaintiffs' failure to exhaust their administrative remedies deprive the Court of Claims of jurisdiction?
  a. Is the challenge to EGLE's authority to issue permit conditions a purely legal issue, thereby exempting it from requirements?
  b. Are the discretionary conditions in the general permit properly subject to judicial review under MCL 24.264?
Trial Court Holding:
The Court of Claims held that it lacked subject-matter jurisdiction as plaintiffs failed to exhaust available administrative remedies.
 
Trial Court Details:
The court reasoned that plaintiffs' contest of EGLE's authority was a matter requiring factual development which should proceed through established administrative channels before being addressed by the court. Jones v Dep’t of Corrections, 185 Mich App 134 (1990); MCL 24.301. For further guidance, consult MCL 24.301, exhaustion doctrine principles, and Michigan administrative law precedents to assess procedural requirements for judicial review.
For Publiciation
    AreasOfLaw
    HighestReviewingCourt
    DocketNumber
    HearingDate: 
    DecisionDate: 
1. ProceduralHistory
2. PertinentFacts    
3. CaseSummaryDetailed
4. CaseImplications
5. ExplainToANonNerdAndHypotheticalScenario
1. HighestCourtMainIssue1
2. HighestCourtMI1Rule
3. HighestCourtMI1Holding
4. HighestCourtMI1Reasoning
5. HighestCourtMI1RulesApplied
6. HighestCourtMainIssue2
7. HighestCourtMI2Rule
8. HighestCourtMI2Holding
9. HighestCourtMI2Reasoning
10. HighestCourtMI2RulesApplied
KeyStatutoryReferencesLanguageUsed
    KeyCourtRulesLanguageUsed
    RecommendationsForStakeholders
    FinancialImpact
    KeyTipsForAttorneys
    JuryInfluenceAssessment
    GlossaryOfDefinitions
    IndustrySpecificImpact
    ClientAdvisorySummary
    ClientRiskEvaluation
TrialCourt
    TrialJudgeName
    TrialCourtMainIssue1
    TrialCourtMainIssue1SubIssue1
    TrialCourtMainIssue1SubIssue2   
    TrialCourtMI1Holding
    TrialCourtMI1Reasoning
    TrialCourtMI1RulesApplied
 
Case Name
For Publiciation
Hearing Date:
11/12/2024
Hearing Date:
Areas of Law Tags
Case No.:
8983783
For Publiciation
Trial Court:
For Publiciation
bottom of page